REVIEWS:
Robert Parker Jr's The Wine Advocate
90 points - December 2008
The dense ruby-hued 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon Estate boasts a sweet nose of incense, toast, charcoal, and red as well as black fruits. Elegant with a first class Bordeaux-like structure, moderate tannin, and outstanding purity and length, it will benefit from 2-4 years of bottle age, and should drink well for 15-20.
Steve Tanzer’s International Wine Cellar
91 points - December 2008
Bright, saturated ruby-red. Aromas of dark cherry, dark berries, tobacco, brown spices and woodsmoke, lifted by a whiff of mint. Juicy, sappy and nicely concentrated, with good density to the slightly exotic flavors of currant, tobacco and smoke. A solidly structured cabernet that finished with firm tannic spine.
Cellar Selection Wine Enthusiast Magazine
93 points - March 2009
Mount Eden makes their Estate Cab the old-fashioned way: to age. The ’05 is quite tannic and shut down right now, with a hard astringency, especially on the finish. However, it’s rich in black currents, mocha and cedar, and is a natural for many years in the cellar. The score could rise considerably after 2011.—S.H.